What Material is Best for Plantation Shutters?

When it comes to quality, attractive and functional window treatments, most homeowners would agree that plantation shutters are at the top of the list. If you are contemplating the purchase of these shutters, you will no doubt find that there are a tonne of options available to you.

Perhaps the most crucial decision that you’ll have to make when sourcing plantation shutters is the type of material that they’re made from. Amongst the most common options include vinyl, Poplar, Basswood and other types of hardwood. As you might imagine, every kind of material offers varying degrees of quality and cost. This begs the question — what material should you choose for the shutters that you’re looking to add to your home?

The following is an overview of the specific pros and cons of each type of material used in the fabrication of plantation shutters.

Vinyl plantation shutters

Among the most economical choice of window treatments are blinds and shutters made from vinyl. These shutters don’t warp and don’t need a finish which helps bring the cost down. That said, there is an artificial look and feel to them, which may not appeal to some people.

Perhaps the best thing about vinyl plantation shutters is that they’re very affordable and readily available. However, these shutters lack the warmth and aesthetic appeal of its’ wooden counterparts. That said, if you are looking for the most affordable solution for your window treatments and do not mind replacing them every few years, then these shutters might be a suitable option for you.

Softwood plantation window shutters

Another great choice of material for plantation shutters are the ones made from softwood like Poplar and Basswood. These materials are relatively light and reasonably soft compared to its’ hardwood counterparts. Basswood, in particular, can be stained and painted in any colour and takes a finish exceptionally well. They also tend to be more affordable as well and more comfortable to work with, which makes softwood a popular choice for DIY plantation shutters.

Of course, softwood has its’ downsides which one ought to be aware of. For one thing, they are softer (as the name implies) than regular wood which makes them vulnerable to dings. Also, shutters made from softwood are limited in size, which limits its’ application. Large softwood plantation shutters will require additional stiles and rails to maintain rigidity.

Hardwood plantation shutters

Plantation shutters made out of genuine hardwood like Mahogany and Teak are at the top tier of plantation shutters in terms of quality. While the initial cost can be significant, many home improvements experts agree that the quality and longevity of hardwood shutters make them well worth it.

In addition to the superior quality and increased durability, hardwood plantation shutters also look better compared to other types of materials regardless of whether they are painted or stained. The aesthetic appeal of natural grain patterns in various kinds of hardwood gives them an elegant and classic look that will never go out of style.


So there you have it — a few of your popular options in terms of material for your plantation shutters. As you may have already realised, each type has its’ own pros and cons. Hence choosing the perfect plantation shutter for your home all boils down to matching each type with your specific needs, budget and aesthetic preferences.